Drink/Food - 3 stars
Great beer selection when they're not out of what you want (previous reviewers were bang on about the flight substitutions) and an OK menu featuring nouveau pub food whose execution is inconsistant. I wish the menu were smaller and focused on doing a few things very well than a large menu that does a lot of things just so-so.
Venue/ Location - 4 stars
Beautiful space. Patio can't be beat. Beer shop on-site as at Mill Street.
Service/ management - 2 stars
After four trips to Amsterdam over the course of the 9 months they've been open, I remain unimpressed by the service and management of the restaurant and bar. The issues other reviewers pointed out months ago continue to plague it now.
On my most recent trip, we were a party of 8 on a weekend and it took close to 2 hours to get seated, then another hour to get our food. A longer wait is of course expected for a large party, but the restaurant was not full, and I saw several large tables sitting free for the duration of our visit. Very frustrating.