No doubt about it: this place is excellent and charming. The lobster roll was probably the best I've ever had: tender, meaty and delicious with a rich nutty flavour. The oysters were as fresh as anywhere I've had in the city, including Rodney's. The wine list is pretty small, but it's smart and the Fumee Blanc matched perfectly. The interior isn't fancy--in fact it's casual to the point of feeling homey, but that's a refreshing change and reflects how focused they are on the food. Definitely one of the best new seafood joints in Toronto--and much more laid back (and affordable) than most.