Considering the other pizza options in the area (Donato's, I'm looking at you) this is darn good pizza.
We ordered a New York style extra-large pizza for delivery - half pepperoni and half green peppers and onions. We also ordered a pretty forgettable salad (except the blue cheese dressing was better quality than anticipated). Delivery was fast and right on time. They do charge a small delivery fee but I guess that's ok in these parts.
The crust was delightfully thin and had a nice crispiness. It was only missing a bit more chewiness but the sauce and toppings made up for it. The sauce to cheese ratio was spot on. The sauce was fresh-tasting, if a little sweet, but definitely not spicy - which is a gimmick some other pizza joints rely on too heavily in my opinion.
We'd definitely order from Coleone's again.