Talk about a hole in the wall!
I heard rumor of Stone Baked Pizzeria from a friend, and last night after joining the mug club at the Illini Inn, we had to stop in and give it a shot.
We climbed up the long staircase, turned the corner and ended up in a very plain room that didn't really look like a pizzeria. The cashier immediately greeted us and asked what we wanted. I don't even recall there being a menu, but my roommate claims he noticed a little sign that said something about cheese, sausage and pepperoni slices.
I got a slice of cheese which wasn't too bad, but seemed like it might have been sitting for a little while before being served, which can be expected at by-the-slice places like this. It was served on a plain paper plate and the 3 of us did the eat-while-walking-to-the-next-bar routine.
The slice was a decent size, and only cost $2.50 tax included. This is not a bad deal at all.
I will have to come back a little more sober and try to figure the place out a little more.