Meh...it's just ok at this point.
Perhaps the problem is that I've never actually gone into the place. I received the whole menu through the mail and I was intrigued so I went on the website and I've ordered from their a handful of times. Each time I try something new to get some variety. Their crab dip was...questionable. I tasted fishier than it should have. The calzones are pretty good...not enought filling though. I tried their spaghetti bake and it was good but too much sauce even though I specified light sauce. It's good but there always seems to be something off about it. I'll try going in next time so they can redeem themselves!