I checked this place out this past Sunday with some friends. We had some drinks and ordered some food, and it didn't really make an impression on me. The food was just okay, and the atmosphere hasn't changed enough from when it was the Garage Bar to feel any different.
I ordered the Spicy burger with the falafel patty. I'm not sure why it's called a falafel patty, as it really didn't taste or feel like a falafel (soggy and wet and bland, not crispy and firm and flavorful). I was happy that I ordered the spicy version of the burger, because without the subtle spiciness of the peppers on the sandwich, it would have been pretty bland and flavorless. My meat-eating friends seemed to enjoy their burgers, for what it's worth. The waffle fries were good, but nothing to rave about...
All in all, I definitely wouldn't put this too high on any list of places to visit in Ohio City, with all the other great options available.