I've been here multiple times and we've also had take out a few different nights. The quality of the food and the service just keeps being amazing. It almost feels too good to be true- like something will give at some point...but it never does.
Each time we eat there, we like to hit the patio to watch the planes, otherwise you definitely need a reservation. The flavors, the quality of the ingredients and the creativity of the dishes make this place shine. Try it all- it's all good. And if there are still specials available that evening, order them! If they bottled their marinara, I'd buy it.
I used to think I wasn't that into Italian food and then I ate here and realized I'd just been settling for poor quality/cheesy/greasy grossness that was labeled Italian. Eat here; it will change your definition of good Italian food.