Considering the 3 star rating says "A-OK," I will definitely agree with that. Brio really is a decent place to go for some Italian. I have had mostly their pastas ranging from their lasagna to their ravioli. You really cannot go wrong with these pastas as they should not be that difficult to make. I also will compliment them on their bread before appetizers. I enjoy sourdough so that is my bias, but they also have these crackers that are quite a treat.
My only con on any of their dishes really is their risotto. The flavor is really lacking for a risotto as it tasted really only of those awful pine nuts.
I'd recommend Brio if you aren't an Italian food snob. It's not bad.