I always liked 5th and Wine because it's close to where I live and they serve a really extensive list of wines. I have had the brie panini, the beef bourguignon and the bison burger. All were very tasty. I especially like their fries which are seasoned with parsley and lemon zest. Yum! The BF loves the hummus plate with is decked out with bread, olives, cucumbers and tzatziki sauce.
They have live music which is nice when it is outside. When they have it indoors, it gets so loud in the restaurant that you can't hear yourself think which defeats the purpose of going out and trying to have dinner conversation. Service is attentive and most of the servers know their wines so they can be helpful in selecting a drink to go with your dinner.
I have never made a reservation and never needed to since my guests and I just walk in and we are always seated right away. But a few weeks ago when my party of 4 walked in at around 6pm , we were only offered a a general seating area with no table and was told we only had 1 hour to dine because the restaurant was booked solid! So call ahead just in case because the place does get booked up.
Great place to have a casual dinner, try a new wine and walk around Old Town.