Went to Acadia the other night for dinner after having read several good reviews. To make a long story short...similar to what other reviewers have posted, the food was inventive and quite tasty. I enjoyed everything I tried, from the Boudin Balls to the bread to the stuffed quail to the fish. I also enjoyed the Southern cocktails that the restaurant has concocted. My one issue - which puts a bit of a damper on the meal but would probably not prevent me from returning - was the small portion sizes (as mentioned by a few others). The piece of fish I was served was tiny, as was the quail. After finishing 2 sides (shared), an appetizer and an entree, I was still hungry! (I'm not a big person). We ended up going down the street for an ice cream after dinner.
There are plenty of good restaurants in Toronto now that are serving interesting food. I may give Acadia another shot as I really did enjoy the food and the drinks, but may wait awhile hoping that the portion sizes improve.