I really like the Priory's cupcakes. I have brought them to the office, given them as birthday gifts, and eaten plenty of them myself and they are always met with rave reviews. My favorite is the "north sider," a vanilla cupcake with PB frosting and clark bar on top. The burnt almond torte is a close second and always a good choice.
I honestly haven't tried anything from this bakery except the cupcakes--because they're SO GOOD that whenever I come here that's what I end up ordering!