This is what I've been looking for in Madison - a cozy, well thought-out, upscale restaurant. Their menu is very unique and quite expansive - while most of the dishes don't sound super appetizing from first glance, there's definitely a lot of finesse that went into the menu dishes. A few standout items were the lamb carpaccio, the fries, and the foie gras. If you go with a group of 6 or so, you can almost try every item on the menu which is super fun!
I highly recommend making reservations on their website beforehand. This place gets packed on weekends and is pretty small to begin with! The ambiance is perfect for this type of shared food. While the place is definitely great for a date night, you just wouldn't be able to try all the great dishes. A group of 4 would be ideal to at least taste a decent amount of their eclectic menu. The service was also superb - the waitresses were all very knowledgeable about the food and wine list.
I HIGHLY recommend this place - definitely some of the best quality food you can find in Madison.