I recently checked out Rusty Nail with a friend. The atmosphere was very small but cute with an old school style to it. It's like walking to Mom's kitchen and dining room. The only thing I didn't care for was the cold breeze when someone walks in the door.
I asked the waitress what the most popular item is on the menu. And she said her absolute favorite was the Tuna Fish Melt. She said it so passionately that I just had to try it. I ordered that with fries.
The wait was not long, and the sandwich was pretty ok. I just wish that it had just a little bit more flavor to it. But all in all, pretty decent. The service was very pleasant, and so I will return to try out another item. And will post an updated review....for now, check it out...it's a cute little restaurant with food that taste a bit like it's from Mom's kitchen. Oh and make sure you bring cash. That's one of my minor pet peeves when restaurants doing accept credit cards, but there is an ATM in the restaurant.