This was one of the first restaurants I ate at when I moved to the city and, several years later, it's still probably my favourite food in Toronto. Read all the other 5 star reviews for details.
In brief: Best pizza I've ever had (duck confit pizza! best margherita anywhere!), great wine list, amazing atmosphere, excellent service, brilliant charcuterie and cheese plates, amazing desserts, and great prices.
Serious fans of Neapolitan pizza will be eternally satisfied with these pies. May this place never close.