Cash-only, local and authentic business that every single person living in Streetsville has been to at least once. Realistically, this place may be a 4 for a lot of people, but it's a childhood staple for me as I've been going here since I was around 6 or 7 back when the old cenotaph was there and I've been here every summer since. The man who runs it is almost always working and he knows exactly how to strike up a conversation - he is the typical small-town business owner in a relatively big town, and he still manages to make you feel special (literally he always knows who my family and I are when we walk in - so nice!) and though the ice cream isn't necessarily cheap, they definitely give you a huge scoop - I always get a single scoop, and it's so filling that I borderline consider it a meal! Either way, every person in Streetsville - or anywhere, really - should come here at least once, even if it's just for the novelty! (But me personally, it's been my third time this year and it's not even June yet!)