During my visit to Pittsburgh, I ventured out to Burgatory in Fox Chapel / Waterworks on the advice of others on Yelp.
THIS PLACE IS AMAZING.
Ordered the "Meat Your Maker" and it was simply a very tasty burger. I didn't like the fact that the burger came with chips instead of fries but I quickly solved that by ordering onion rings. The onion rings were huge, by the way.
Finally, the Smore's Shake.
Quite simply it was the greatest milkshake that I've ever had in my life. It was chocolatey and had ground up graham crackers in it and it just made the greatest and most flavorful texture that I've ever experienced in a milkshake.
They describe them as "heavenly shakes" and yes... I was in heaven with every single sip.
5 stars. Come here, come often.