I live nearby and this is my go to pizza place. I've never been a fan of the dimpled crust pizza so I usually stay away from that. However, The Sicilian squares are, hands down, the best pizza in the area. The pizza crust is more spongy with a nice crispy buttery texture. Flavorful! It is a must try if you haven't yet.
Usual order: Large Sicilian Square (Whole: Extra Cheese, light sauce, 1/2: pineapple, 1/2: pepperoni, sausage & mushrooms).
I am actually placing an order now for delivery tomorrow to surprise the wife with my return home. I will also be adding pictures of the Sicilian Square when I receive my pizza tomorrow. Make it a pretty Anotonio's!