After a disappointing first experience, I decided to give these guys another try. My first go was 1 star but now I would give them 3-3.5. The bruschetta appetizer and cheese platter were both excellent and the pastas this time were better than our first experience but still just okay. Maybe their pasta is a different flavour of Italian cooking that doesn't appeal to me. For reference, my go-to spots for knock your socks off pasta are Locale (Aurora, King City) and Roman Bistro (Newmarket).
One tip for guests who are not accustomed to "al dente" noodles is to ask for your noodles to be cooked well done.