This place deserves a 4.5*
One word : authentic.
This place is a "you get what you see" type of restaurant.
No it's not fancy and the staff will speak loudly greek to one another, regulars and the tv (that obviously is on Greek channels). AND THATS AWESOME.
Food : nothing short of delicious. I've tasted many things on the menu and have yet to be disappointed. The wine comes in the little tins and the Greek coffee is always good.
Decor : simple. No frills. A couple of cute greek paintings here and there.
Service : I love the waitress (I have not asked permission to mention her name). She's so nice and attentive.
This place is a hidden gem.
I would give it 5* but I'm not a fan of the lighting (but that's just me!)