I love the central location, the clean interior and the attentive service at Reuben's. I'll also admit that the food is pretty decent. All these components point towards a 4-star rating.
However, I ordered their "famous" smoked meat sandwich for $15.99 and it just did not compare to the ones i've had at Schwartz's or Main's. The meat was tender, but it lacked a certain depth of flavor, even after requesting the "fattty" smoked meat. Also, the $15.99 price point, is a bit steeper than what you would find elsewhere.
Reuben's is nice with comfortable seating and attentive waitstaff. However, it is slightly tourist-centered and their pricing reflects this. Reuben's is still a good dining option in the area. Their dessert display is also quite impressive.
***3.5 stars***