I had a apple pie and it was wonderful. I ate it so quickly, I had to order the banana cream pie to go...$4 per slice was a bit steep but because they were so tasty and the place had so much character, I think they can get away with it. It is great to have another place to go to just hang out, rather than having to go to a cupcake place, because naturally, that is the other place I hang out...
The apple pie crust was on point. I dislike dry crusts but this was very moist and sweet. The banana cream pie was more of a cup like crust and that one was a bit "crustier." It was not my favorite crust but the filling was great.
They also give free coffee to students. I told them I was a teacher and he gave me the coffee anyways (not sure if this is for all teachers). The store itself is kind of small but I love the personality of it. They use a lot of local products. The staff was also friendly and personable. They wanted to know what I thought of the food and carried on a small conversation. I will be back, and can not wait for fall pies!!