OK - I love this place. Not because the food is the greatest (although the cinco fromaggio pizza is wonderful, the buffalo and wild mushroom meatloaf is very good and the French onion soup might just be the best in the city), but because it is such a great atmosphere. It is an absolutely beautiful space. However, for religious patrons, it might feel a little sacrilegious. But for drunken heathens like me, it's great fun. I always take out of towners here because it is such a unique space. The beer isn't bad either. I love my agnostic mother's comment, the first time she walked in the place - "This is beautiful. They should do this with ALL of the churches!"