Gigi's is every bit deserving of 5 stars and a top-class rating.
First Off: Gigi's dinner entree menu isn't constant (and thus not online) - however, don't let that deter you. Every day they have 3-5 delish and amazing entrees artfully crafted from local ingredients. On the night my wife and I ate here for our one-week wedding anniversary (woo!) the options were all so amazing it was nerve racking to decide! We ended up ordering the Filet Mignon and Sea Scallops entrees, respectively. Both were prepared in top-chef fashion, came out quickly, and were absolutely amazing - the flavors of the dishes were so forward and perfectly balanced. Absolutely amazing - probably the best Filet Mignon and Sea Scallops we have had. Boom.
The wine-list here is fantastic as well - many great standards to choose from: If you happen to be a red wine lover and Scotch drinker, try the 'Barbera' - a wonderfully fruity yet surprisingly smokey and amazing red wine.
The ambiance is perfectly romantic and nicely lit - you can't pick a better date spot. Everyone who worked here was incredibly friendly, nice, and helpful as well. Those details round off the excellent wine and food at Gigi's - a 5 Star dining experience on the East Side.