This is more of a 3.5 star place in my book.
I like the atmosphere in this nice corner spot in the Atwood area. There's some great artwork and some awesome bathroom decor as well. The bread is excellent. Ideal for a sandwich really with just the right crisp and sourness to it. I had a really yummy biali here as well. On top of that they serve Just coffee, a really solid Madison local.
Where things kind of fall apart for me a bit is the pastrami itself. It was pretty salty for my taste. It was noticeable enough to make what should have been an awesome sandwich a little subpar. Would definitely come back to give it another shot but the salty pastrami was enough for me to round down to 3 stars.