I always reject the popular, but we got the cannoli which I read about here and on chowhound. It was fantastic.
We came after they closed, and probably looked like puppy dogs in the window from the inside. They were nice enough to let us in, and pick out something to eat. They were so lovely, that I was certain they were just going to Give the stuff to us. We paid, but the warmth was appreciated just as much. 6 stars.