This is one of my most favorite restaurants in town. I've been eating here for special occasions for at least 14 years or so.
That being said, I found last night's dinner to only be OK. My group started with the French Onion Soup, the gazpacho special, and the Baked Goat Cheese Salad. The gazpacho was great! The soup was a touch too sweet and the salad, frankly, was not worth it. One circle of cheese on top of greens. For $14.
I found my steak to be good, but not great. In my mind the steaks have always been great so I'm not sure what happened. The fries, very sadly, were a touch over cooked.
Our dessert was the caramel creme brulee and it was divine! Excellent! Our server was also very friendly.
All of this being said, "OK" at Mon Ami Gabi is "great" anywhere else. I just have so many perfect meals in my memory that last night's meal didn't quite match up.