I had the appetizer sampler. The chicken tenders and curds were awesome. The other stuff was just ok. I also got the Portabella Penne. It was perfect. The Caesar salad that came with it wasn't anything special.
So basically, half the food was ok and the other half was fantastic. I'd give it 4.5 stars, so I'm rounding up. I'm not sure why the ratings are low because this place has some great food.