I pride myself in "knowing" Old Town. I feel like I've at least seen, if not been to most places. So when my friends said, "let's go to OTT" I was baffled.
The place is about as "local" as you can get. It isn't "Scottsdale." No glitz and glamour. Regulars get special treatment. The crowd is all wearing polos, no heels, no dance floor. The crowd when I went there was all generally older (not that you're older, folks, just over 40).
The place is not my cup of tea in general, but I can see that it would be a good place to be a regular at. They had a decent selection of beer, craft beer, wines, and mixed drinks. If you're looking for something "not Scottsdale" - this is your place.