I personally do not like fish but adore seafood of all kinds, especially lobster. Their lobster rolls are absolutely amazing!! The lobster meat is fresh, tender and juicy, and the bun is buttered and crisp. The dressing they use is not a heavy mayo based one, its more of a lemon butter or something. The only negative is the size and price, its pretty small and pricey. Keep in mind it is only available on wednesdays and the weekend.
I have also tried their calamari and it is quite good, the batter is light and crispy. Their fries do tend to be over fried and they lack seasoning. That being said when the fries are fried properly and you add some salt they are pretty tasty. I wish they had more fried seafood options though, shrimp would be nice.