Went here on a Monday on a whim because we needed food. We got the $12 burger special - pint and pretty much any $13 burger on the menu with a side of fries or salad. Great deal! I got the Philly Cheesesteak burger. Lots of jalapeno and cream cheese, didn't seem to taste the onion or red pepper. He got the Bloomington, which was very similar to a Big Mac with a little twist in the sauce. The salad was delicious and fresh, light on dressing - it was almost invisible. I got the fries and they were solid. I was definitely impressed by their patties for a place boasting craft beer.
Minor drawbacks: It's a small place and it was a game night, so it was a bit noisy. I also only found out they were out of the beer I wanted when I went to order, which was kind of a bummer.
I plan to go back when it gets warmer and try other things (especially burgers).
Not really any complaints but it just doesn't have the nostalgia wow factor to be 5 star worthy. However, that's subject to change ;)