It's funny because six years ago, my review would have been 5 stars. Not so much now. I used to eat at Dotty's all the time at the old location. Now that it's moved, I think I've been there once.
I love the burgers, cheese curds, and the fries, but now that it's a sit-down place with waiters and stuff, I feel like their kind-of-pricey-burgers should be like a meal thing.
I guess what it really is, is that old place was a lot more fun. The new location seems like it has more of a "I just drove my SUV 40 miles to see a hockey game in Madison and now I'm hungry" feel to it.