We got the Judge Sampler to-go. Our first time ever trying this restaurant. Very good food! The half slab of ribs was a lil crunchy on the end peices but the middle pieces were delish! Pulled pork, brisket and chicken were great! Being as we ordered a family sized combo meal, our only complaint is the side of mac n cheese was extremely small (you pick 2 sides with the Judge sampler) My 2-yr old, who barely eats as it is, ate have of the mac. The fries were really good, also a lil small of a portion but not as bad as the mac. I'd say 4.5 with the portion of mac n cheese and we havent dined in yet so i cant comment on that..