Coffee: 3 stars. Their roasts are hit or miss.
Breakfast Sandwich: Keeps me alive. I'm in Madison for a work project for 6 months. I've had one of these for breakfast probably 90% of mornings. They're amazing, delicious, and keep you full till lunch.
Mexican Mocha: Also delicious, but can't do it every day.
Sandwiches: I bought a sandwich once. Some kind of beefy or pastrami thing. It was $9, and basically an oversized cocktail sandwich. I was supremely disappointed, and won't be trying that again.
Wines: I bought a couple bottles off their "Top 10 List": Honestly, they weren't bad but I wasn't impressed. If this is 7/100, what are the rest of them like?
Yelp deals: 5 stars. 50% off coffee for checking in??? Are you kidding??? Steal!
Overall 4 stars: People are great, service is excellent, coffee is acceptable, prices with "check-in" deal is unbeatable. And the breakfast sandwiches are my lifeblood