Some friends and I came on a Saturday night at 5 and stayed till 8. There were very few patrons, which was too bad because this place has a lot to offer: decent organic food, a nice view of the lake, live jazz music starting at 7. Unfortunately, with little advertising or visibility, I worry about its future success!
While I generally recommend Captain's Cove, I must warn against ordering the "World's Healthiest Dessert" featuring the Xocai chocolate the restaurant hawks. It consists of a medium-sized chocolate cookie, a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and a square of the chocolate itself. The cookie is gritty and has a horrible flavor, and this dessert will set you back $14 - the same as most of the entrees on the menu! Yikes! Do yourself a favor and order one of the cheesecakes, which are quite nice and reasonably priced.