Let me start by saying that I am a beer snob and I have ZERO issue paying a premium for, good food or drink. However their beer, which is why you come here, is WAY overpriced. While they offer quality and selection, paying $9 for what you can get at 5 other places in town for $5 is a bit much.
Service can make up for some of that, but try do not excel at that either.
Middleton and the West side have been in need a good spot for good beer, but there are now places that offer some of the same hard to find brews at a much better price. On that note happy hour was a joke, I'll take my money to Vintage, Freehouse, Craftsman, and Mr Brews.