I've tried to give this Miller Tavern a chance on several occasions and every single time I am left disappointed. I will stick to the Miller on Yonge Street - it's way better and the staff are much nicer and better informed.
I was at the Bay Street location last week and I ordered the Seafood Boo-Yah-Base (I think the spelling is clever). When it arrived I had to question whether I received the right dish or not. It was a plate overflowing with seafood - to the point that it did not look appetizing and the seafood was falling off my plate.....I couldn't move the move around the food so I can eat it politely in front of my client, and there was absolutely no broth. It was dry as a bone. When I finally brought this to our waitresses attention she told me that's how it's supposed to be. She even mentioned to me that someone from "cirque du soliel" had ordered it and loved it. I felt like saying well "Tamara from Toronto doesn't like it" but I didn't want to be rude in front of my client. Anyway, moving on...to several minutes later as I couldn't even get the attention of our waitress. I finally asked if I could have the Lobster Cob salad instead, which, by the way is $29. Serves me right...I should have known better. I got a freezing cold plate with iceberg lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, almost frozen tomatoes and cold and gross lobster, which I think must have been in the freezer/fridge for days. It was one of those salads you get a self serve station that is prepared in advanced and sits in the fridge all day. I can get a much better salad at Ikea for a fraction of the price. I've had the Lobster Cob at the Miller on Yonge street and it's delicious. This one was horrible. Btw, my salad arrived as everyone was finishing their meal so it was not fun! Anyway,...I'm done with this place I gave this restaurant at least 4 or 5 chances and now I'm done....I will never go back. I have not had a good meal here ever!