Great atmosphere, some of the friendliest restaurant staff I've ever met. The food was delicious and the prices were very reasonable. A really nice atmosphere with a good amount of room to eat outside on a nice summer night. I had the Penne Arabiata both times, delicious and a great portion!
This won't apply to most, but this was also my choice for the best place to have a large group meal for about 20 people on Bloor west for a wedding rehearsal dinner. We visited about 10 other restaurants on the street and they all insisted we had to choose from a special "group menu" where a three course meal was forced and everything cost twice as much. Classico just let us use the normal menu with some extra salad shared amongst everyone and we just had the space booked off for us.