First of all.. 3 and 1/2 stars. Come on Madison. This place is the best. I lived in Madison for 7 years and I would see about 85% of my movies here. (The other 15% was IMAX or if this theater didn't carry the movie I wanted to see).
I have never had a bad experience other than a theater was a little too dirty.
You pick your own seats, they have amazing popcorn and you can buy booze. Plus a bar on the roof.
Compared to the other choices in town, hands down one of my favorites.