I have to agree with the other yelpers, this place is awesome! Hands down some of the best pizza I've ever had if not the best. The smell when you enter is amazing. Their ingredients are local and fresh and they have a great variety of toppings. Their pizzas are pretty thin and doesn't overly stuff me but that's a good thing. The ambiance isn't super flashy but then again everything done at Pizza Brutta is simply done and I think that adds to the charm of this place. Definitely a must try in Madison!