I've picked up everything at Star Pop from board games and books for my kids to vintage ties and clothing for myself. Troy, the owner, has even called me MONTHS later to let me know he found things I'd forgotten I ever requested!
Troy has a keen eye and a sharp memory, and he travels constantly to add to his inventory. The ever-evolving selection at Star Pop is terrific, and Troy is knowledgeable about every single item in the store.
Well worth planning to spend some extra time on Waterloo!
(Also, Star Pop DOES accept credit cards now via Square!)