I think Porktropolis has the BBQ thing nailed.
If Smoky Jon's is "Best of Madison", then Porktropolis should be proud because I think their BBQ is way better than Smoky Jon's.
The sides are just not very good, and I would not recommend them. Each time I bought them with the meat, people other than me were disappointed.
Great choice for carry-out as long as you skip the sides.