I had to try out the new store in Tivoli Village. It's a brand new, beautiful place and you can tell the staff are still learning.
We ordered a pastrami and Swiss on rye ($18+), a side house salad with raspberry vinaigrette dressing ($4) and an extra kosher pickle ($3.50).
I'm giving three stars for several reasons:
1. What we received was a full house salad (charged $11) with Italian dressing.
- Italian dressing tasted off. Something wasn't right. Salad was pretty plain for $11 charge which we only wanted a small side salad.
2. No extra pickle that we ordered.
3. Pastrami sandwich with a kosher pickle
- As many other reviews have stated, this sandwich is not worth $18+. The pastrami was hand carved and very tender, but 1/2 pound of pastrami for $18 is way overpriced. Kosher pickle that came with the sandwich was Amazing! I don't know how Canters makes their pickles, but I could eat these all day.
4. Forgot the side potato salad that came with the sandwich
- The potato salad tasted store bought. I won't go as far to say it was the grossest potato salad I've ever eaten... but I could only manage one bite. I would expect better, much better from a Jewish Deli.
5. Our server left my credit card in her chip machine and forgot to return it. When I asked for my card, she said "oh my gosh, I keep leaving these cards in there!" She was extremely nice and helpful as a server, and very pretty, but leaving my card behind is inexcusable.