First I have to say this place is ultra casual! small lobby with room for about 6 people, and a large patio out back. tables are all set with a roll of paper towels.
Service across the counter and again when pizza was brought out to us was friendly and efficient. a little later the delivery guy gladly retrieved us a box for leftovers.
If you follow my reviews you may remember my pizza roots are deep, I have been making quality pies since I was 15 years old. I feel solidly qualified to judge any pizza.
I often tell the silly joke, "pizza is like sex, even when it sucks, it's still pizza"
Well Let me tell you Grand avenue Pizza doesn't suck!!!! It is in fact professionally made with high quality ingredients. It's that New York style pie that none of the chains can replicate. The cheese was amazing and the sauce was perfect. The dough was expertly tossed and baked to absolute perfection.
No beer, coke in cans, napkins on a roll, and crushed peppers and parmesan cheese in little packs cost 1 star but I'm nit-picking now aren't I?
I really did like this place and I would surely recommend giving them a try.