Our family of five just stayed at the Gainey Ranch for 5 nights and had a great time overall. I was torn between a 4 and 3 rating but the high daily fee and charges for Internet access made me lean towards a three. Here is what I would say are the pros and cons:
Pros: nice rooms, comfortable beds, great maid service. Restaurant was a '4', good food and not as overpriced as I would have expected. Location worked out great for us, we went hiking and horse back riding 15-30 minutes north of the hotel and went to dinner in the downtown area just 10 minutes away. Pool was great fun for the kids albeit as others mentioned a bit dirty.
Cons: we had two rooms so paid 40 per night on 'resort fees' and I could not think of one benefit we got from the fee. They overcharged me for 12 for 'resort recreation' that I need to inquire about as we never rented any recreation items. The Internet charges on top of a resort fee are just ridiculous, if this is the norm for all Hyatt hotels I will avoid them in the future. The bigger con for us outside of the Internet fees was the rooms are not sound proofed at all. Our neighbors got up at 5am every morning and we could hear their entire conversation. The Hyatt also had a nightly concert/band (likely what our resort fee covered) and unfortunately the music was so loud we could not relax and read or watch. The Hyatt should have forewarned us we would have been situated in a room right on top of loud music. I would say bathrooms were a con too, one of our rooms had a standard showerDand the other had a very small bathtub shower/combo.
It was a nice hotel but I would not stay again unless I knew they had concerts and started offering free wireless.