Had this place bookmarked even before this place got on You Gotta Eat Here, but after seeing it on the show I was more excited to go there. I ordered the dillicious and overall it was pretty good! I liked that all the grilled cheese orders came with a pickle, which helps to cut the greasiness of the cheese. However I did wish that there was more dill in my 'Dillicious' sandwich, since the cheese was pretty dominant and covered up most of the other flavours. With the sandwich on it's own, probably only worth a 3.5, but the service was quite friendly and the prices were very affordable for a "gourmet grilled cheese" which sometimes start from $8 and up. Here I believe sandwiches start at around $6. So with the good service and affordable pricing I decided to bump it up a little. May come back to try the soup 'cause it looked pretty enticing on tv!