Ideally, I would like to give this place a 2.5. It definitely does not live up to the hype of the photos that are provided. It looks great, it tastes decent. We ordered the soft shell crab burger and the lobster roll. The soft shell crab burger ($16) was somehow both larger and smaller than I imagined. It was smaller in terms of what I've seen in photos; but it was large because it comes out of the bun, the bun only really contains its body with the legs hanging out - it's a weird illusion. Taste wise, I did appreciate it. I do like me some soft shell crab. It was delicious but it also wasn't stunning. The lobster roll ($15) was underwhelming if anything. The taste didn't pop. It wasn't tangy enough, and although it was fresh, it came off a little bland. The fries also weren't all that crispy but did fit well with the sandwiches/burgers.
It's actually a little pricey for a "quick meal" so it definitely wouldn't be my go to. Once in a while, if I'm in that area and want soft shell crab and something fried, I would stop by, but I wouldn't make the effort to go here unless the craving was reaaaal strong.