Location, location, location!
It's a hotel. It's a place to sleep. You don't get a hotel smack dab in the middle of things and expect to hole up do you? There may be noise...and there may not be, depending on when you're staying.
For me, the experience was nice. The wife and I caught a play, watched the game, and visited a couple of pubs for my birthday celebration.
The front desk was kind and helpful, the rooms were clean and modern. Things can always be better, but this was affordable and worth my dollars.
I will be back.