We decided to check out Ithaca when we saw that some of our friends had been there recently. I've lived in the area all my life and I never noticed it so I was surprised that there was a Greek restaurant so close by.
Located in a plaza on Highway 7 and McCowan, walking in was a surprise as the decor was very interesting and not what you would expect from the outside. Service was professional but not very warm. The restaurant still had a fair amount of people in it when we got there with more coming in. Very spacious and good for groups probably.
The menu has quite a bit of variety and we were a little surprised by the prices. We hoped that at least the portion would be big. We got garlic bread before our meals, which was good. Very generous with the butter. They were also very generous with the feta cheese on our Greek salads, but the dressing was definitely too sour.
We got the "light" version of the pork souvlaki and chicken souvlaki meal and we were definitely disappointed to see that it was almost all vegetables. They overwhelmed the plate and it looked like at least two thirds of it was vegetables, like we ordered vegetables with a side of meat. And they weren't even well made - it was all steamed and bland and on the soft side. The potatoes were definitely taken out of soup so at least there was flavor in them. The meal cost about 13-14 dollars each.
However, the souvlaki itself (despite how little there was) was quite good. Crisp on the outside, tender on the inside and flavorful. Not good enough to make up for the price though. Portion was definitely not worth it. My suggestion? It's a bit out of the way but Hunter's Pizza at Huntingwood and Birchmount is far cheaper and gives you much more for similar quality - maybe the souvlaki isn't as good but it's still a good meal and at least you're getting your money's worth.