This was the ultimate so-so meal. There were four of us in our party. We arrived at 11 am on a Saturday to celebrate a birthday with (what we thought would be) a tasty lunch.
The highs were very high. The she crab soup is as tasty as I've had. Just the right amount of sherry to cream ratio- not easy to achieve. One person in my party also commented that the chicken salad was very good.
The lows were so low. I had the BBQ chicken medallions. Yuck! Rubbery chicken slathered in what tasted like bottled sauce. I also had smashed potatoes and broccoli- both very poorly executed. Two in my party had the Mac n Cheese as a side and neither liked it. "Bland" "Looks like they ran out of cheese". Yet another ordered a medium-well burger and I'm pretty sure when she cut into it I heard the cow scream "Ouch". Medium at best. It has been my experience that if they can't cook a burger right other menu items will be sub-par as well.
While the soup was very good, it could not rescue this meal from several culinary boo-boos.
Red Rocks Cafe- Birkdale Village: C-