This was one of the first pizza places I tried after moving to town based on Yelp reviews. I ordered a Large Sicilian Deluxe and 12 Spicy Garlic Parmesan Wings for delivery. It ended up running me over $30 which I was a little shocked by but my own fault for not looking at prices. I'm not worried about the price except for the fact that what I received in my opinion was just an average run of the mill pizza with some wings. Nothing really special. I figured this was a local Mom and Pop shop but it didn't seem like that. The pizza itself was pretty bland and dry. It was a step above something like Dominos in my opinion. Like I said, not terrible, but nothing special. The wings were more of the same. Fairly dry and hardly and sauce. Although the sauce I did get had a good taste.
The delivery was timely but looking at the experience as a whole, I feel like there are better options in the area that I'd consider over Supremo's when it comes to cost vs. product.